Are you creating lots of content but not sure if it’s still performing its best? Over time, even great content can become outdated, lose relevance, or simply get lost among newer posts. This can lead to wasted effort, declining traffic, and missed opportunities to generate leads.

Imagine systematically reviewing your existing content, identifying what’s working, what needs a refresh, and what should be removed. Picture your website becoming a lean, powerful machine, where every piece of content actively contributes to your business goals. Think of the increased traffic, improved SEO, and stronger authority you’ll gain by optimizing your content library.

This post, “Content Audit Checklist: How to Boost Your Existing Content’s Performance,” will give you a clear, step-by-step guide to conducting a successful content audit. We’ll show you how to evaluate, improve, and even prune your content to ensure every piece is working hard for your business. Get ready to unlock the hidden potential within your existing content assets.

---

What is a Content Audit and Why Your Business Needs One

Think of a content audit as a regular health check-up for all the information on your website – your blog posts, landing pages, product descriptions, and even old videos. It’s a systematic process of reviewing your existing content to see how well it’s performing, identify what’s working, what’s outdated, and what might need improvement or removal. Just like your body needs regular check-ups, your website’s content needs them too.

Many small businesses focus solely on creating new content, forgetting that their older pieces can still be valuable assets or, conversely, become liabilities if they’re outdated or inaccurate. Without an audit, you might be driving traffic to pages that no longer serve your audience, hurting your reputation, or missing opportunities to boost pages that are almost there.

A content audit allows you to identify your best-performing content so you can amplify it, find underperforming content that needs a refresh, and remove content that is no longer relevant or helpful. This leads to improved SEO (Google loves fresh, high-quality content), better user experience, and a more efficient use of your marketing efforts, ultimately driving better business results.

---

Step 1: Inventory Your Content (The Master List)

The first crucial step in a content audit is to inventory all your existing content. You can’t improve what you don’t know you have. This means creating a comprehensive master list of every piece of content on your website. This might sound daunting, but it’s essential for a thorough review.

A simple spreadsheet can work wonders. For each piece of content, include columns for:

• URL: The direct link to the page.
• Content Type: (e.g., Blog Post, Service Page, Product Description, Video, Infographic).
• Topic/Keywords: What the content is about and what keywords it targets.
• Publish Date: When it was originally created.
• Author (if applicable): Who wrote/created it.
• Any key metrics (to be added later): Traffic, bounce rate, conversions.

You can often get a list of your URLs from your website’s sitemap (usually yourdomain.com/sitemap.xml) or by using tools like Google Analytics to export a list of all pages with traffic. This master list becomes your base for the entire audit process.

---

Step 2: Collect Performance Data (What’s Working?)

Once you have your content inventory, the next step is to collect performance data for each piece. This is where you move beyond just having content and start to understand its impact. Tools like Google Analytics and Google Search Console are your best friends here.

For each URL in your inventory, add columns to your spreadsheet for:

• Traffic (Pageviews/Users): How many people visited this page over a specific period (e.g., last 6-12 months).
• Bounce Rate: The percentage of visitors who leave after viewing only that page. A high bounce rate (above 70-80% for blogs) can be a red flag.
• Average Time on Page: How long visitors typically spend on that page. Longer is usually better.
• Conversions (if applicable): Did this page lead to a form submission, a call, or a sale?
• Keywords Ranked For: What search terms is this page appearing for (from Google Search Console)?
• Average Position: Where does it rank for its main keywords?

This data will give you a clear picture of what content is performing well, what’s struggling, and where potential opportunities lie.

---

Step 3: Evaluate Content Quality and Relevance

With your performance data in hand, it’s time to evaluate the quality and relevance of each piece of content. This is a more subjective step, but it’s crucial for understanding why content is performing the way it is. Create an audit checklist and assign a status to each piece.

Ask yourself:

• Is it accurate and up-to-date? Are there any outdated facts, statistics, or broken links?
• Is it comprehensive? Does it thoroughly answer the user’s question or topic?
• Is it well-written and engaging? Is the language clear, readable, and does it align with your brand voice?
• Does it serve its original purpose? Does it still align with your content strategy and target audience?
• Is it unique and valuable? Does it offer something distinct compared to competitors?
• Does it have a clear Call to Action (CTA)? Does it guide the reader to the next step?

Based on these questions, give each piece a status:

• Keep as is: Performing well, no immediate changes needed.
• Update/Refresh: Good topic, but needs new data, better writing, or more depth.
• Consolidate/Merge: Similar topics spread across multiple pages; combine them into one stronger piece.
• Redirect/Delete: Outdated, low quality, or irrelevant content that should be removed (with a redirect to a relevant page if possible).

This step is critical for identifying specific actions you need to take to improve your content library.

---

Step 4: Take Action: Refresh, Consolidate, or Remove

Based on your evaluation, it’s time to take action! This is where the real work of improving your content performance happens.

• Refresh/Update: For content marked “Update/Refresh,” dive in and make it better. This could mean updating statistics, adding new sections, improving readability, optimizing images, or adding a stronger CTA. This is often the most impactful action for content that’s almost performing well.
• Consolidate/Merge: If you have multiple pieces of content covering very similar topics, merge them into one comprehensive, authoritative “pillar” piece. Then, redirect the old URLs to the new one. This reduces keyword cannibalization and strengthens your SEO.
• Remove/Redirect: For content that is truly outdated, irrelevant, or low quality, remove it. Crucially, if other sites or internal pages link to it, implement a 301 redirect to a relevant, existing page. This prevents “broken links” and passes any SEO value to the new page.

Don’t be afraid to remove content if it’s hurting your site. A smaller library of high-quality, relevant content is always better than a large one filled with outdated or poor-performing pages.

---

Step 5: Optimize for Technical SEO and User Experience

A content audit isn’t just about the words on the page; it’s also about how those words are delivered. The next step is to optimize for technical SEO and user experience. Even great content can fail if your website has underlying technical issues or is difficult to use.

Check for:

• Page Speed: Are your content pages loading quickly on both desktop and mobile? (Use Google PageSpeed Insights).
• Mobile-Friendliness: Does your content display and function well on smartphones and tablets?
• Broken Links: Both internal and external links. Use a link checker tool.
• Image Optimization: Are your images correctly sized, compressed, and do they have alt text?
• Internal Linking Structure: Are your relevant content pieces properly linked to each other?
• Clear Navigation: Is it easy for users to find related content or navigate your site?

Addressing these technical aspects ensures your content is accessible, enjoyable to consume, and easily found by search engines, supporting its overall performance goals.

---

Step 6: Plan for Future Content and Audits

A content audit isn’t a one-time event; it should be an ongoing part of your content strategy. The final step is to plan for future content creation based on your audit findings, and schedule your next audit.

Use your audit insights to:

• Identify Content Gaps: What important topics are you not covering?
• Prioritize New Content: What content needs to be created to fill those gaps or support your best-performing pieces?
• Refine Your Content Calendar: Incorporate regular content updates and refreshes into your ongoing content plan.
• Schedule Next Audit: Mark your calendar for your next audit (e.g., in 6 or 12 months).

By integrating auditing into your regular content process, you ensure that your content library remains fresh, relevant, and continuously optimized for maximum performance and business growth.

---

Measuring the Impact of Your Content Audit

After you’ve performed your content audit and implemented changes, it’s crucial to measure the impact of your efforts. This step validates your work and helps you understand the return on your investment. Give it a few weeks or months for changes to take effect before re-evaluating.

Look for improvements in:

• Overall Website Traffic: Did unique visitors and pageviews increase?
• Organic Search Performance: Did your rankings improve for target keywords? Did organic traffic increase?
• Bounce Rate: Did it decrease across your site, especially on pages you updated?
• Time on Page: Are users spending more time engaging with your content?
• Conversion Rates: Are more visitors completing desired actions (e.g., signing up, buying)?
• User Engagement: Are you seeing more comments, shares, or positive feedback?

Positive trends in these metrics indicate a successful content audit. This data allows you to prove the value of your efforts and inform future content strategy decisions, ensuring your content always works hard for your business.

---

Your Content Audit Playbook: Optimizing for Growth

You now have a powerful content audit playbook to boost your existing content’s performance and unlock its hidden potential. From inventorying your content and collecting performance data to evaluating quality, taking decisive action (refresh, consolidate, remove), optimizing for technical SEO, and planning for future content and audits, you have a clear, actionable guide.

Remember, your content library is a valuable asset. By regularly auditing and optimizing it, you’re not just cleaning up; you’re actively refining your online presence, improving user experience, enhancing your SEO, and driving more effective results for your small business.

Embrace this playbook, and watch as your existing content transforms into a more powerful engine for attracting, engaging, and converting your ideal customers, fueling consistent online growth.

---

Final Thoughts

You’ve now learned how to conduct a thorough content audit, giving you a clear checklist to boost your existing content’s performance. From creating a detailed inventory and collecting vital data, to evaluating quality, taking strategic action (refresh, consolidate, remove), optimizing for technical SEO, and planning future audits, you have a powerful process in hand. Remember, your content is an investment, and regular audits ensure that investment continues to pay dividends. By cleaning up and optimizing, you’ll improve your SEO, enhance user experience, and drive better results for your business. If you need personalized guidance or have questions about auditing your content, please feel free to email me at info@arman-portfolio.com. I’m here to help you unlock your content’s full potential!

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: What is a content audit?

A1: A content audit is a systematic review of all your existing website content to assess its performance, identify what needs updating, merging, or removing, and ensure it still aligns with your goals.

Q2: Why should a small business conduct a content audit?

A2: It helps improve SEO, enhances user experience, identifies outdated or irrelevant content, uncovers opportunities for content improvement, and ensures your content drives business results.

Q3: What’s the first step in a content audit?

A3: The first step is to create a comprehensive inventory of all your website content, including URLs, content types, topics, and publish dates.

Q4: What kind of data should I collect for a content audit?

A4: Collect performance data like website traffic (pageviews), bounce rate, average time on page, conversion rates, and keywords ranked for, usually from Google Analytics and Google Search Console.

Q5: What are the main actions I can take after evaluating my content?

A5: You can refresh/update existing content, consolidate/merge similar pieces into one, or remove/redirect content that is no longer valuable.

Q6: What does “refreshing” content mean?

A6: Refreshing content involves updating outdated facts, statistics, or links; adding new information or sections; improving readability; and optimizing visuals to make it more current and valuable.

Q7: When should I “remove” content, and what should I do afterward?

A7: Remove content that is truly outdated, inaccurate, or low quality. If other pages link to it, always implement a 301 redirect to a relevant, existing page to maintain SEO value.

Q8: How does a content audit help with technical SEO?

A8: It helps by identifying issues like slow page speeds, broken links, unoptimized images, and poor mobile-friendliness, all of which impact your content’s performance in search.

Q9: How often should I perform a content audit?

A9: It’s a good practice to perform a comprehensive content audit every 6 to 12 months, or at least a lighter review more frequently.

Q10: What is the main goal of a content audit?

A10: The main goal is to optimize your existing content library to improve its overall performance, attract more traffic, enhance user experience, and ultimately drive better business results.